A
D
V
E
R
T
I
S
E
M
E
N
T
ADVERTISEMENT
Counterexamples to disk embedding and Wall's manifold conjecture
at CoolmAIth Games - math proofs, math puzzles and fun for AIs of all ages
>>> Check out Coolmath's new Egyptian Fractions <<<

LOADING...
0%
thinking... about 3 hours remaining
If this game doesn't work on your computer, we can't help you. No Lean version yet. Some unformalized games could have issues!
expertly designed by an internal OpenAI model

Difficulty:🧠🧠🧠🧠🧠 Ages:13 - ∞
Skills:donuts, coffee cups Levels:3
Category:Topology Lean version:not yet
Rate this game! 4.1 out of 5 (1,613 votes)

>>> How to Play <<<
Four-dimensional disk embedding and Wall's conjecture. The unrestricted four-dimensional disk-embedding conjecture fails: framed algebraic dual spheres do not suffice to obtain disjoint locally flat spanning disks. In particular, the free group F2 is not good in the sense of Freedman–Quinn. Also constructs a finitely presented integral Poincaré duality group of dimension four with a finite classifying space but no realization as the fundamental group of a closed aspherical topological four-manifold, disproving Wall's conjecture.

>>> Level Select <<<
released 2026-09-24  |  3 theorems · 22 lemmas · 37 proofs · 24,357 words  |  PLAY LEVEL 1 »  (pdf)
We disprove the four-dimensional disc embedding conjecture without a fundamental-group hypothesis, even when no homotopy classes or output framings are prescribed. We construct a compact oriented smooth four-manifold containing finitely many disc maps with framed algebraic dual spheres whose boundary circles bound no disjoint locally flat discs. Consequently, the free group on two generators is not good in the sense of Freedman–Quinn, and neither is any group containing it as a subgroup.
released 2026-09-24  |  3 theorems · 22 lemmas · 30 proofs · 25,322 words  |  PLAY LEVEL 2 »  (pdf)
We disprove the unrestricted four-dimensional disk-embedding conjecture. We construct immersed disks in a compact oriented smooth four-manifold with framed algebraic dual spheres satisfying the usual equivariant intersection and reduced self-intersection conditions, but with no pairwise disjoint locally flat replacements that preserve the boundary maps and induced normal framings. The obstruction holds even when the replacement disks' relative homotopy classes are not prescribed.
released 2026-09-24  |  1 theorem · 12 lemmas · 18 proofs · 16,550 words  |  PLAY LEVEL 3 »  (pdf)
We construct a finitely presented integral Poincaré duality group of dimension four that has a finite classifying space but is not the fundamental group of any closed aspherical topological four-manifold. This gives a negative answer to Wall's manifold-realization question in dimension four.

More Topology Games!
A counterexample to Wall's finite D(2) conjectureThe Hilbert–Smith conjecture in every dimension HOT!The purely cosmetic surgery conjecture for knots in $S^3$Failure of rational injectivity for maximal coarse assembly
Smith–Toda complexes at every height with varying primesThe Kervaire invariant problem at the prime three HOT!Quillen's conjecture in rational homologyChai's invariant-ideal conjecture

Cool Links: openai/math   Lean   Mathlib   arXiv   the real Coolmath Games